Young psychosis patients who use cannabis have worse cognitive function than non-using patients

A meta-analysis of 14 studies found that young psychosis patients who currently use cannabis performed worse on IQ, verbal learning, working memory, and motor inhibition tests, contradicting the idea that cannabis-using patients have better cognition.

Bogaty, Sophia E R et al.·Journal of psychiatric research·2018·Strong EvidenceMeta-Analysis
RTHC-01597Meta AnalysisStrong Evidence2018RETHINKTHC RESEARCH DATABASErethinkthc.com/research

Quick Facts

Study Type
Meta-Analysis
Evidence
Strong Evidence
Sample
Not reported

What This Study Found

Previous research had suggested that psychosis patients with lifetime cannabis use appeared to have better cognitive function than non-using patients. This meta-analysis challenged that finding by focusing specifically on current cannabis users and younger patients.

Across 14 studies, young psychosis patients who were currently using cannabis performed worse than non-using patients on several cognitive measures: premorbid IQ, current IQ, verbal learning, verbal working memory, and motor inhibition. This contradicts the narrative of cannabis-using psychosis patients having superior cognition.

One exception was conceptual set-shifting, where cannabis-using patients actually outperformed non-users. This isolated advantage amidst broader deficits suggests different cognitive profiles in cannabis-using versus non-using psychosis patients.

Age was a moderating factor, with older age predicting worse performance in processing speed, sustained attention, and verbal memory among cannabis users, but better performance in verbal learning and verbal fluency.

Key Numbers

308 studies identified, 14 met inclusion criteria. Cannabis-using patients performed worse on: premorbid IQ, current IQ, verbal learning, verbal working memory, motor inhibition. Cannabis users outperformed non-users on conceptual set-shifting. Increasing age predicted worse cognitive performance in several domains among cannabis users.

How They Did This

Systematic search of 308 studies identified 14 comparing neurocognition between current cannabis users and non-users with psychotic disorders, with mean age between 15 and 45 years. Effect sizes were extracted from cognitive test performance and analyzed using random effects modeling with moderator analyses.

Why This Research Matters

Understanding the cognitive effects of cannabis in psychosis is important for treatment planning and for understanding the biology of cannabis-associated psychosis. If cannabis-using patients have worse cognition, this challenges the idea that they represent a "healthier" subgroup and suggests cannabis may actively impair cognitive function on top of psychosis-related deficits.

The Bigger Picture

This meta-analysis helps resolve a confusing finding in the literature. The earlier observation that cannabis-using psychosis patients had better cognition likely reflected a comparison of lifetime users (many of whom had stopped) rather than current users. When the analysis focuses on those actively using cannabis, the cognitive picture is worse, suggesting cannabis compounds psychosis-related cognitive impairment.

What This Study Doesn't Tell Us

The studies used varied cognitive assessments, making direct comparison imperfect. The age range (15-45) is broad. Current cannabis use was defined differently across studies. The meta-analysis cannot determine whether cannabis caused the cognitive deficits or whether patients with worse cognition were more likely to continue using. Sample sizes within individual studies varied.

Questions This Raises

  • ?Why do cannabis-using psychosis patients perform better on set-shifting but worse on most other cognitive tests?
  • ?Does the cognitive impairment associated with cannabis use in psychosis reverse with cessation?
  • ?Could the different cognitive profiles inform different treatment approaches?

Trust & Context

Key Stat:
Cannabis-using psychosis patients performed worse on 5 cognitive domains but better on set-shifting
Evidence Grade:
This is a meta-analysis synthesizing 14 studies, providing strong evidence for the cognitive effects of current cannabis use in young psychosis patients.
Study Age:
Published in 2018. Research on cannabis and cognition in psychosis continues to evolve.
Original Title:
Meta-analysis of neurocognition in young psychosis patients with current cannabis use.
Published In:
Journal of psychiatric research, 99, 22-32 (2018)
Database ID:
RTHC-01597

Evidence Hierarchy

Meta-Analysis / Systematic ReviewCombines many studies into one answer
This study
Randomized Controlled Trial
Cohort / Case-Control
Cross-Sectional / Observational
Case Report / Animal Study

Combines results from multiple studies to find an overall pattern.

What do these levels mean? →

Frequently Asked Questions

Does cannabis make psychosis patients think less clearly?

This meta-analysis found that psychosis patients who currently use cannabis scored worse on IQ tests, verbal learning, working memory, and motor inhibition compared to non-using patients. The effect was more pronounced with increasing age.

Is there anything cannabis users with psychosis are better at?

Interestingly, cannabis-using psychosis patients outperformed non-users on tests of conceptual set-shifting, which involves the ability to change thinking strategies. This isolated advantage amid broader deficits suggests a distinctive cognitive profile.

Read More on RethinkTHC

Cite This Study

RTHC-01597·https://rethinkthc.com/research/RTHC-01597

APA

Bogaty, Sophia E R; Lee, Rico S C; Hickie, Ian B; Hermens, Daniel F. (2018). Meta-analysis of neurocognition in young psychosis patients with current cannabis use.. Journal of psychiatric research, 99, 22-32. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jpsychires.2018.01.010

MLA

Bogaty, Sophia E R, et al. "Meta-analysis of neurocognition in young psychosis patients with current cannabis use.." Journal of psychiatric research, 2018. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jpsychires.2018.01.010

RethinkTHC

RethinkTHC Research Database. "Meta-analysis of neurocognition in young psychosis patients ..." RTHC-01597. Retrieved from https://rethinkthc.com/research/bogaty-2018-metaanalysis-of-neurocognition-in

Access the Original Study

Study data sourced from PubMed, a service of the U.S. National Library of Medicine, National Institutes of Health.

This study breakdown was produced by the RethinkTHC research team. We analyze and report published research findings without making health recommendations. All interpretations are based solely on the published abstract and study data.