College students who used all three substances had 10 times higher risk of impaired driving

Among 367 college drinkers, those who also used marijuana and nicotine had over 10 times the odds of driving under the influence and riding with an impaired driver compared to alcohol-only users.

Hultgren, Brittney A et al.·Accident; analysis and prevention·2021·Moderate EvidenceLongitudinal Cohort
RTHC-03213Longitudinal CohortModerate Evidence2021RETHINKTHC RESEARCH DATABASErethinkthc.com/research

Quick Facts

Study Type
Longitudinal Cohort
Evidence
Moderate Evidence
Sample
N=367

What This Study Found

Compared to alcohol-only users, students using all three substances (alcohol, marijuana, nicotine) had dramatically higher odds of DUI (OR=10.33) and riding with an impaired driver (OR=10.22). Marijuana-only users also had elevated DUI risk (OR=5.44 between-person; OR=9.08 on specific occasions). On days when both alcohol and marijuana were used, riding with an impaired driver was nearly 4 times more likely (OR=3.86).

Key Numbers

367 students. All three substances vs. alcohol only: DUI OR=10.33, RWID OR=10.22. Marijuana-only users vs. alcohol-only: DUI OR=5.44. Marijuana-only occasions vs. alcohol-only occasions: DUI OR=9.08. Alcohol+marijuana occasions: RWID OR=3.86. Confidence intervals were wide.

How They Did This

Burst design study of 367 college student drinkers with past-year marijuana and/or nicotine use. Assessed on two consecutive weekends for three semesters. Logistic and multilevel logistic models examined between- and within-person associations of substance combinations with DUI and RWID.

Why This Research Matters

Prevention programs typically focus on alcohol-impaired driving. This study shows that polysubstance use dramatically increases driving risk beyond alcohol alone, suggesting prevention efforts need to address substance combinations rather than single substances.

The Bigger Picture

The finding that marijuana-only occasions carried high DUI risk (OR=9.08) is notable because cannabis-impaired driving receives less attention than alcohol-impaired driving. The multiplicative risk of combining all three substances underscores that polysubstance use creates qualitatively different risk profiles.

What This Study Doesn't Tell Us

Wide confidence intervals reflect small cell sizes for some substance combinations. Self-reported substance use and driving behavior. College student sample limits generalizability. Cannot determine impairment level at time of driving.

Questions This Raises

  • ?Why does nicotine add to DUI risk beyond alcohol and marijuana?
  • ?Are polysubstance users also engaging in heavier use of each substance?
  • ?Would campus-level interventions targeting polysubstance use reduce impaired driving?

Trust & Context

Key Stat:
10x higher DUI odds when all three substances were used together
Evidence Grade:
Longitudinal burst design captures within-person effects, but wide confidence intervals and self-reported measures are limitations.
Study Age:
2021 study with data from a Midwestern university.
Original Title:
Alcohol, marijuana, and nicotine use as predictors of impaired driving and riding with an impaired driver among college students who engage in polysubstance use.
Published In:
Accident; analysis and prevention, 160, 106341 (2021)
Database ID:
RTHC-03213

Evidence Hierarchy

Meta-Analysis / Systematic Review
Randomized Controlled Trial
Cohort / Case-ControlFollows or compares groups over time
This study
Cross-Sectional / Observational
Case Report / Animal Study

Follows a group of people over time to track how outcomes develop.

What do these levels mean? →

Frequently Asked Questions

Did marijuana alone increase DUI risk?

Yes. Students who reported marijuana use (without alcohol on that occasion) had 9.08 times higher odds of driving under the influence compared to alcohol-only occasions.

Why were the odds ratios so large?

The large effect sizes likely reflect that polysubstance users represent a higher-risk subgroup overall, but the wide confidence intervals mean the precise magnitude is uncertain.

Read More on RethinkTHC

Cite This Study

RTHC-03213·https://rethinkthc.com/research/RTHC-03213

APA

Hultgren, Brittney A; Waldron, Katja A; Mallett, Kimberly A; Turrisi, Rob. (2021). Alcohol, marijuana, and nicotine use as predictors of impaired driving and riding with an impaired driver among college students who engage in polysubstance use.. Accident; analysis and prevention, 160, 106341. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aap.2021.106341

MLA

Hultgren, Brittney A, et al. "Alcohol, marijuana, and nicotine use as predictors of impaired driving and riding with an impaired driver among college students who engage in polysubstance use.." Accident; analysis and prevention, 2021. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aap.2021.106341

RethinkTHC

RethinkTHC Research Database. "Alcohol, marijuana, and nicotine use as predictors of impair..." RTHC-03213. Retrieved from https://rethinkthc.com/research/hultgren-2021-alcohol-marijuana-and-nicotine

Access the Original Study

Study data sourced from PubMed, a service of the U.S. National Library of Medicine, National Institutes of Health.

This study breakdown was produced by the RethinkTHC research team. We analyze and report published research findings without making health recommendations. All interpretations are based solely on the published abstract and study data.